Showing posts with label frustrated expectations. Show all posts
Showing posts with label frustrated expectations. Show all posts

Friday, January 28, 2011

Improving Normal Dungeons

This week I've talked about a number of problems with dungeons, and suggested that many of the perceived problems with heroic dungeons are really caused by normal dungeons being marginalized. I've criticized the awarding of Justice Points of normal bosses as an ineffective solution to this problem because it only serves to further marginalize normal drops.

Now I am going to present some of my solutions to these problems. These are real solutions designed to create a space for normal dungeons. With each of these solutions, I present what I think is a realistic timeframe for when this could be implemented given the current state of the game. These changes are radical, but probably the best thing about WoW and about Blizzard is that radical changes are considered if they are good changes. I will be submitting all of these on the suggestion forum.1

Fully Separate Normal and Heroic Difficulties
I've talked about this before, but it really is part of the solution. The current model for progression is normal dungeon to heroic dungeon to normal raid to heroic raid. The ideal would be to have two separate streams, normal dungeon to normal raid and heroic dungeon to heroic raid, possibly with some heroic players running a few normal dungeons just after reaching maximum level to get some gear.

Whether you choose to approach normal or heroic difficulty should be a legitimate choice based on your preferred playstyle and time commitment. Normal difficulty should not be a stepping stone on the way of heroic. Currently every progression stage has to be two things: 1) challenging for those who will never reach beyond that stage and 2) a gear grind for those who don't think of that stage as an accomplishment. At the same time as many people are struggling with heroics, many other people are already bored of running them every day for their 70 Victory Points. Having these groups play together is a recipe for conflict.

In this model the gear from heroic dungeons should be equal level to the gear from normal raids and heroic dungeons should be harder than normal raids. Both normal dungeons and heroic dungeons should be beatable in quest gear with good play - good play being a relative term depending on the difficulty level. Raids would be tuned expecting players to be mostly geared in appropriate dungeon gear. Because normal raids and heroic dungeons would give the same gear, those who played normal dungeons would be ready to try heroic raids to see see if they wanted to switch streams. But this would be a function of practice leading to increased play skill, not a function of getting more gear.

Timeline: I thought it was important to bring this is as an ultimate goal, but it is completely unrealistic to implement this until the next expansion. Changes being made now should be seen, in part, as preparation for this new state.

Less Gear from Vendors
When the emblems system first premiered in Burning Crusade it seemed like a really great idea. We all know the frustration of waiting for those last one or two drops to complete our gear sets, so having a way that we acquire a few pieces of gear for certain with sufficient work seemed like a good remedy. But in Burning Crusade, gearing up for raids involved a lot of running heroics for drops. In Cataclysm faction vendors and Justice Points provide so much variety in gear that dungeon drops are becoming insignificant. Waiting for that one drop your need is even more frustrating because it was the only drop you needed in the first place. Sometimes I would wonder why dungeons even had cloth gloves in them at all.

The amount of slots that can be covered by reputation vendors should be reduced, and the rate at which points are earned should be reduced as well. Points should be a way to fill in for slots you just can't seem to get rather than the primary reason to run dungeons. Each difficulty setting should earn points only at their own difficulty. So heroic players earn Victory Points but not Justice Points. This would prevent the marginalization or normal difficulty gear.

Timeline: In Cataclysm this ship has already sailed at the gear cannot be taken back. It might be possible, though, to hybridize this concept in with the current one by not giving out Justice Points like candy in heroic dungeons as soon as the next major content patch.

Three Dungeon Difficulties
Normal difficulty dungeons are currently trying to fulfill two incompatible roles. First of all, they are the ends of the stories of each zone. The storylines presented through quests end in assaults on enemy stongholds that are the dungeons. For this reason, normal dungeons need to be extremely accessible to everyone, and they need to be accessible at the level appropriate to the zones. As a result, only a handful of those dungeons are appropriate for maximum level characters, and it creates the impression that normal difficulty is a throwaway to be played through once only.

I am proposing a third difficulty be added - Story mode - that is intended to be played through at a level appropriate to the zone the dungeon is in. This difficulty would replace the current normal difficulty (i.e. all current normal dungeons would instead be the "story" dungeons) and a new normal difficulty would be placed between heroic and story. Normal difficulty would be for maximum level characters, and would present many of the same challenges as heroic difficulty but be more forgiving in terms of damage outlay, dps checks and time to adapt to or avoid fatal attacks.

This would mean that those who want to play at a lower difficulty level would have a full range of dungeons to experience, including dungeons like Deadmines and Shadowfang Keep that have been updated for maximum level. Normal dungeons could be something that people choose to play with their play time, rather than being seen as just glorified group quests.

Timeline: I honestly think this should be implemented in 4.1 or 4.2. That may sound completely crazy because of the amount of work involved, but I think it's pretty easy to overestimate how much work it would really be. These new dungeons would be exactly the same as heroic dungeons, but with some numbers dialed down. Because they are being tuned to be easier, they do not need to be tuned as tightly, so applying a ratio across the board for damage and health would probably suffice as a first pass with a second added here or there to abilities that you have to react to to stay alive. With future dungeons more care could be put in to balance properly based on lessons learned from the first batch. The infrastructure already exists for difficulty levels, so it is hard to believe that adding another would be a more massive project than is normally taken on in major content patches.

Dungeon Fragment Finder
Limited play time is a definite hindrance to experiencing content, especially if normal dungeons were a little harder than they are now. With the current dungeon lockout system, however, it would be possible to implement a system where someone could essentially save their progress through a dungeon2 and then later look for a group to finish it. I necessary people who were not saved at the same point could be brought in, since people are generally pretty happy to join a dungeon run already in progress to reach the end boss faster. A good progress saving system would also be helpful for guilds running dungeons together who play for limited amounts of time.

Timeline: Patch 4.2 or 4.3. I'm sure there are some technical challenges to implementing this system, and it is a lower priority suggestion. It would be a valuable upgrade to the dungeon finder, though, to make dungeons more playable with limited play time.

Normal Difficulty Achievements
Achievements add a lot of replayability to heroic dungeons. When a boss has been mastered, there is something else to try for. Similar achievements should exist in normal to add the same amount of replayability.

Timeline: I think this could be added any time after the third difficulty, but if another difficulty is not added then achievements would need to wait for the next expansion. Unfortunately normal dungeons are just too easy to overgear to make these achievements even feel like achievements, and most of the normal difficulty dungeons are not for maximum level characters.

Less Loot Inflation
Reduce a "tier" of gear to only 7 or 8 item levels. This would help with scaling problems from the beginning to the end of the expansion and also reduce the role that overgearing plays in defeating content.

Timeline: I'd really like to see this change in 4.1, but I'm not holding my breath.

Better Information About What Went Wrong
This is actually something the developers have mentioned they would like to do and I wholeheartedly support it for normal difficulty. If you are killed by Rajh's Inferno Leap, getting a message telling you that that was what killed you, and that in order to survive it you have to get away from where he is landing, would be a great addition. I know that currently this is primarily intended for heroic difficulty, but in the long run if normal and heroic difficulty were separate then I don't think this would be necessary for heroic difficulty. Playing heroic would indicate a level of comfort with figuring things out on your own.

Timeline: I think we'll see something like this in patch 4.1 or 4.2.

Suppose all of these things had been done for Cataclysm, what state would we be in now? Imagine that by the time you completed all of your solo play you had access to one piece of 333 loot from a quest chain and two pieces from getting to revered with all the factions. The rest of your loot is 325 from quests. You choose, based on your own preference, whether you want to play normal or heroic difficulty and start looking for dungeons of that difficulty.

In terms of execution and play skill requirements - not in absolute terms - heroic bosses are close to the same challenge level as the easier normal raid bosses currently are. A heroic boss dungeon boss would put up nearly as much of a fight for a newly geared 85 as Halfus, Double Dragon, Magmaw or Omnitron would right now for a full 346 geared group. If you choose normal you find that those bosses are a little harder than current normal bosses, expecially in the sense of being less forgiving of mistakes, but that they have significant amounts of instruction in terms of raid warnings plus indications of what went wrong if you lose. By succeeding in these dungeons you would be able to gradually upgrade all your gear to 333 for normal or 341 for heroic, giving you in the neighborhood of a 10-12% increase in suvivability, healing and damage. Introductory raid bosses would be toned down in their difficulty from where they are now by a noticeable margin (remember that if you were playing heroic you would not do the bosses on normal first), and final bosses could be either a little easier or stay the same given appropriate adjustments for lower gear numbers.

Casual players would feel that they were accomplishing something by playing normal dungeons with their limited play time. "Hardcore Casual" players would get to approach heroic dungeons with like-minded players. Servers would have a small number of heroic guilds and a larger number of normal guilds. Raid accessibility would be increased - a goal of developers since Wrath - without watering down content for those who like the hardest challenges.

This would allow a wider array of players to access dungeon and raid content, generate less friction by putting players with very different play styles and goals together less frequently, and give players more space to set their own goals instead of being forced down the one progression path.

If you think these changes sound insane or counterproductive, I'd love to hear about it how terrible I am. If you think that they sound awesome, help to spread the word. Blizzard is very responsive to customer feedback, and the more a good idea gets echoed in the player base, the more likely the are to notice it.


1. So far I have quite a remarkable record of my suggestions being implemented, which probably means that I generally have made suggestions that the developers were already planning on doing anyway. I hope I'm behind the curve on this stuff too and they already have it in the works.

2. This is already essentially possible with the lockout system by just extending your last instance, but the interface is somewhat hidden and not user friendly.

Thursday, January 27, 2011

Justice for Normals

The developers have heard the complaints about heroic dungeons and they have responded. In patch 4.0.6 the rate at which you will be able to earn Justice Points by doing normal dungeons will be greatly increased. Not only are they doubling the Justice Points earned by doing a daily random to 140, they are giving 30 Justice Points per boss for Halls of Origination, Lost City of Tol'vir and Grim Batol.

The idea, it seems, is to make normal dungeons more rewarding and to help players enter heroic dungeons with more gear. But how does this goal measure up to reality?

First of all, let's consider how good a source of Justice Points normal dungeons will actually be. Bosses being worth 30 versus 70 Justice Points seems like a big decrease, but they also die a lot faster. Heroic Anraphet has 4.9M health while normal Anraphet has only 2M. If you wanted to farm Justice Points and had the choice of fighting either of those bosses repeatedly, you would choose normal for the simple reason that 30 divided by 70 is greater than 2 divided by 4.9.

It's not that simple, of course, but heroic trash has a lot more health too. The ratio isn't consistent, but aside from the fairly common 309,960 / 387,450 mobs, heroic trash usually has about 75% more health than normal trash and bosses have between 2.3 and 2.8 times as much health. Adding up the total health of normal versus heroic Halls of Origination gives the slight edge to heroic in terms of Justice Points per mob health, and of course the time to run between mobs is the same on both difficulties.

So heroic is the clear winner for Justice Points assuming that you have the same amount of difficulty with both. If your healer drinks more on heroic, if your dps die more, if you ever wipe or stop to discuss strategy, if you mark mobs for CCing when you could be using AoE abilities to do more damage, then normal is a better place for you to earn Justice Points. The number of slots you can expect to get 346 items in from normal dungeons and heroics will reach 10 of 16. If this does prepare you for heroics, it also leaves you with few things left to upgrade when you get there.

I think all of this runs the risk of substantially mischaracterizing the people who are going to play normal difficulty dungeons on an ongoing basis. I seem to be talking as if everyone who plays the game is only interested in a frantic gear grind. I know that this is not the case, but I think that how the frantic gear grind works has ripple effects that will affect everyone. So let's divide the audience for normal dungeons in two categories: 1) Those who are playing normal dungeons because they like to play WoW and that is what is accessible to them in the play time they have; and 2) Those who are playing normal dungeons only as a stepping stone to gear up for heroics.

The first group is a group that doesn't get talked about a lot. If you only log in for 30-90 minutes at a time (maybe a little more sometimes on weekends) and you only play WoW two to three times a week then it is a pretty safe bet that you also don't spend a lot of your time talking about WoW on forums, reading WoW blogs or otherwise making your presence known in the WoW community. The dungeon finder was a huge boon to people who play in this category because they could run dungeons in the limited time they actually play the game. The dungeon finder can still work for this group of players, but only for normal, not for heroic instances. A typical random heroic takes too long to complete, and may be too difficult.

The second group has a playstyle that is going to be antithetical to the first. If I felt like the best way to upgrade my chest piece was to run normal Halls of Origination 11 times then I would do it, but I certainly wouldn't want to take my time doing it, explain fights, or possibly even exchange pleasantries.

By making normal dungeons a viable source of gear for people who are having trouble with heroic dungeons, these changes will force these two groups to play together, which will be less fun for everyone. They will be a disservice to the first group because they diminish the rewards of the dungeon in favour of rewards to be purchased from a vendor. They will be a disservice to the second group because they give people the impression that the way to solve their gameplay problems is by grinding better gear. If Corla's friends are ascending, then at 346 chest is not going to help you, so people are going to end up grinding up gear in normal dungeons that have become boring for lack of challenge and then find that they are still having the same problems with heroics they were having before.

Tomorrow I'll be concluding my Normal Dungeon Manifesto with a list of suggestions that would improve normal dungeons by making normal dungeons seem like a worthwhile goal unto themselves and by responding to the needs of players who run normal dungeons.

Wednesday, January 26, 2011

Bad Habits

Cataclysm was a rough time for many players who had developed very bad dungeon habits in Wrath of the Lich King. The group up and AoE model for trash, often taking more than one pull at a time, didn't translate to the new dungeons and the new healing model. This adjustment to CCing, paying attention to enemy abilities, and otherwise playing well was never going to last, however, and for the most part my guildmates have already returned to killing everything at once in heroic dungeons because 359 gear allows that.

But if 359 gear enables the group up and AoE strategy in heroics, what level of gear is required to enable that strategy in normal?

Let's look at the abilities from normal and heroic trash. Here I'm intentionally choosing some of the most deadly trash mobs available in level 85 dungeons. These mobs aren't necessarily that dangerous if handled correctly, but will easily kill individuals or groups if their abilities are ignored.

Ascendant Waterlashers have wiped more than one group I've been in because their front cone has been facing the group. This cone lasts 4 seconds and deals damage every 0.25 seconds. On normal it averages 1500 damage per tick, on heroic it averages 4000 damage per tick.

Temple Shadowlancers channel Pact of Darkness doing high damage in melee range, and often killing off melee dps who do not interrupt it while also putting a strain on tank healing. Pact is channeled and deals damage every 1 second. On normal the average damage is 4500, on heroic it is 18000.

The penalty for not dealing with an ability correctly on normal is in the range of 27000 damage to a single character or up to 96000 damage spread around the group. On heroic it is instead over 108000 to an individual or upwards of 256000 damage divided among the group.

Not all heroic versus normal mobs have such extreme differences. In many cases, the damage difference seems to be around 50%, but spells that you are supposed to avoid or play around are often much higher. All of this brings us to the fact that if you walk into normal with some 333 gear and some 346 gear then there is little reason to CC trash or react to abilities. Failing to interrupt a spell that an enemy is casting doesn't mean very much. Facing the enemies the right way doesn't mean very much. Targeting the right enemy first or burning down a dangerous enemy doesn't mean very much. The gear you can get from soloing is adequate to group up and AoE in normal instances.

Equally important are the boss abilities. On normal, General Umbriss' Blitz deals 30k, on heroic is deals 100k. On normal, Erudax's Shadow Gale deals 3k on the first tick, increasing to 30k by the last one for a total of 165k, on heroic it deals 10k on the first tick, increasing to 100k for a total of 550k. On normal failure to dispel Anhuur's Divine Reckoning means 15k damage, on heroic it means 45k. It is hard to directly compare bosses outside of level 85 dungeons because you encounter them at different levels, but the numbers are still telling. The rocks High Priestess Azil throws on normal deal only 35k damage, which is survivable for a level 82 character. On heroic they deal 400k damage which is not survivable for anyone. Ozruk's Shatter is similar, dealing only 30k on normal - a hit you would expect your tank to simply take - and 150k on heroic - an instant fatality to new geared heroic characters. With the new healing system, I often see healers saying, "I can't heal stupid." In normal dungeons, you can.

When the developers say that players who are having trouble with heroic difficulty may want to try normal difficulty to learn the fights, they are ignoring the fact that you can't really learn many of these fights on normal. Learning only happens when there is a motivation for it. When your tank gets killed by Pistol Barrage the first time you face Godfrey, you ask questions like, "Can you move out of that ability or should you use a cooldown? Will he move to keep facing you when he's casting or can you escape without taking any damage at all?" If we imagined a level 85 normal version of Shadowfang Keep, the tank would be taking manageable damage while standing in the barrage. Those questions may never get asked, and while the healer would walk out of the fight saying that it seemed like a lot of damage, a win would be quite possible while ignoring all the mechanics. If you never have to ask questions like that to win, then you never learn to ask questions like that when you aren't winning. What is going wrong in heroics becomes a mystery - it seems like you just can't heal enough.

You don't learn Altairus' upwind/downwind ability when you can heal the fight with the haste penalty. You don't learn Throngus' Phalanx ability when there is no penalty for standing in front of him and your healer isn't in danger of running out of mana. In some cases key abilities don't even exist on normal. Normal Ozruk doesn't cast Paralyze, normal Beauty pulls separately from her pups, normal Setesh doesn't have attackable portals.

The longer you stay in normal dungeons, the more gear you get, the easier they become. But the bad habits that people form in normal dungeons are going to do more harm than the gear they collect can do good. This is why we see healers complaining about getting kicked from groups after the dps make unhealable mistakes. After enough experience in normals, "unhealable" leaves your head as a concept.

Tomorrow I'm going to look at the solution that the developers are implementing in 4.0.6 to make normal dungeons more attractive - increased Justice Point rewards - and what effects we should realistically expect from that change.

Tuesday, January 25, 2011

Normal Dungeons Manifesto

My first excursion into a heroic dungeon was somewhat challenging. It was Stonecore, which is undoubtedly one of the harder heroics, and Corborus gave us a bit of a run for our money. Of course it was because we were playing terribly, getting hit by his charge while he was underground, but it left me with a good feeling that heroics really were harder now, and that encounter mechanics could not be ignored in favour of overgearing. As much as I like the new heroic design, there are clearly many who don't, and they regularly show up on forums to talk about how heroics are no longer fun for them. My gut reaction is to defend heroics because I don't want them to change or to be made easier, but that adversarial relationship is just masking the real problem. It's not that heroic dungeons aren't fun, it's that normal dungeons aren't fun.

This post is the first in a four part series on what went wrong with dungeons in Cataclysm from the perspective of a casual player. Today I'll be talking about how players can acquire gear and why normal dungeons are out of place in that progression. Tomorrow will be about how the current system of dungeons creates a dichotomy between normal and heroic dungeons where the best way to beat a heroic is by playing well and the best way to beat a normal is by having better gear. Thursday I will look at the role of Justice Points and what we can expect from the change to the way normal-difficulty players can earn Justice Points in 4.0.6. On Friday I'll present some real solutions to some of these problems.

Before I get to the topic I really want to discuss, and that is where gear comes from for non-heroic players, I want to talk about a few of the common concerns that are echoed around the forums. I don't want to dismiss 45 minute queue times for dps, the length of time it takes to clear heroic dungeons, or the challenges of doing difficult content with people you don't know through the dungeon finder, because I think all of these are legitimate issues for some people. But I think that too many people are trying to find solutions for problems that they perceive with heroic dungeons when they should be trying to find solutions to problems with normal dungeons. Almost everyone wants content to be tuned so that it feels like a challenge but it is ultimately surmountable. Unfortunately, a single dungeon cannot be that to all people - it has to run the gamut from unbeatably hard to boringly simple depending on the players that enter it. In focusing all efforts on finding ways to fix heroics, we are trying to make them into something they can't be - content for everyone. There are two levels of difficulty for dungeons, and if we work on fixing the problems with normal difficulty dungeons then instead of having one level of difficulty that is meant to be something for everyone, we could have two meaningful levels of difficulty and allow people to play the one they have the most fun with.

So why aren't normal dungeons working? One problem is definitely that there are only three of them for level 85 characters. This doesn't give enough variety for players who want to player normals dungeons. Even if all eight heroic dungeons were playable at level 85, though, they still wouldn't see nearly enough play.

A casual player, or any player, has most likely leveled up by going through the various zones and doing the quests. While some people have have leveled mostly from archaeology, this is certainly the exception rather than the norm. Having done all those quests means having gathered quest rewards, and having a decent amount of reputation will all of the new factions in Cataclysm. Questing alone will get you to, or pretty close to, Revered with the various factions. That means a lot of gear, including many 346 pieces, are readily available to players who have done nothing but solo content. Let's take a look at what a cloth-wearer1 could have in terms of gear from solo content alone.

You can get 346 items in the following slots: Back, Chest, Finger, Finger, Weapon (2-handed)
You can get 333 items in the following slots: Feet, Hands, Head, Legs, Waist

That means you are settling for less than 333's for your Neck, Shoulder, Wrist, Trinkets and Wand. Of course there are dungeon quests that give you 333's for Shoulder and Wrist, so one run through each of two dungeons guarantees those upgrades. That leaves you with only 4 gear slots that do not have 333 gear in them by the time you have run two normal instances even if you don't get any drops. Some drops in normal instances may be side-grades for some of your slots, but you already have many 346 items making many of those drops completely useless.

In fact, with a little bit of effort and an appropriate profession, you can hit the 329 ilvl requirement for heroics without actually doing any normal dungeons. Normal dungeons are a stepping stone that most players don't even need to step on if they want to avoid it.

Given this is it no wonder that players are complaining about heroics instead of enjoying normal dungeons. What is there to enjoy? Normal difficulty dungeons were virtually designed as throw-aways to be run once at most. Furthermore, many of the upgrades you could in theory get in normal dungeons have Justice Point vendor items in the same slot, making any upgrades that can be found feel temporary at best.

Some blue posts have suggested to people that if they find heroics too hard, they may want to consider gearing up a little more. This advice from blue posters would be helpful if normal dungeons were actually a place to gear up, but for the most part they are not. While it is possible that running a few normal dungeons could increase average item level by 1 or 2, either by filling out a rep to revered or by actually finding a drop, that kind of gear upgrade is not really what people who are struggling with heroics need.

Wrath of the Lich King gave a large part of - probably most of - the player base the impression that for dungeons (if not for raids) these difficulties should really be called easy and normal. There was no hard mode for Wrath dungeons, but there was a very trivial mode that people spent little or no time in. Part of making heroics harder, should have been trying to reverse this impression. Normal mode for dungeons should be what it is for raids: the difficulty that the majority of people find success in. Unfortunately by making the rewards of normal difficulty dungeons easy to match or beat through quests and solo play, the developers trivialized the rewards of normal dungeons and left players little reason to want to spend time in them.

Tomorrow I'll talk about why running dungeons on normal difficulty could be making things harder, rather than easier, for players who want to graduate from one to the other.


1. I am assuming that they can make use of either Spirit or Hit, so I guess I am excluding shadow priests.

Friday, January 7, 2011

I Feel Like a Paladin

Lots to digest in the patch 4.0.6 notes, but here's the big one:

Power Word: Shield now scales from 87% of spell power, up from 41.8%. Base absorb increased by 110%, from 3906 to 8136. Now costs 25% of base mana, up from 19% of base mana.

Now I think it was obvious that I was clamouring for some kind of buff to Power Word: Shield for while. That being said, I'm not sure that giving Discipline Priests a 29k on-demand instant heal is the solution to that problem. Compared to Greater Heal it would have 67% more throughput and 20% more efficiency without a Rapture proc. As before, Rapture procs are larger than the cost of the shield. Power Word: Shield would have higher throughput than a four target Prayer of Healing.

I guess the question is, what is Power Word: Shield supposed to be doing? There are three states is seems to be able to occupy: 1) High throughput and efficiency plus all the benefits of being a shield instead of a heal so cast it all the time instead of regular heals; 2) Mediocre throughput and low efficiency without a Rapture proc so cast it once every 15 seconds on the tank like clockwork; and 3) Useless.

The ground I think we'd like to see Power Word: Shield occupy is where we actually cast it on someone who is at low health when they are in danger of dying so that another heal can land, or on someone who is about to take massive damage to make sure they live through it, but that we don't cast it all the time as a staple heal.

I really see only one way to accomplish that, and I don't think anyone is going to like me for suggesting it: lower the duration. If Power Word: Shield only lasted 8 seconds then you wouldn't go around spamming it on people as a heal because it would fall off without doing anything too much of the time. If someone was low and you were worried about them dying before they got a heal, it would work just as well as it does now for that purpose - but would have an extra "hidden" cost that it might go to waste. If someone was about to take a big hit, 8 seconds would provide lots of time.

I'm now getting very nervous about what's going to happen to discipline priests. The more buffed you get, the bigger the nerf is going to be. Normally this kind of swing is reserved for paladins, who tend to either be overpowered or underpowered while priests have traditionally been in the middle. We may soon return to the days where discipline priests were a strange kind of healer: you are crazy if you don't bring one, and almost equally crazy if you bring two.

Monday, November 29, 2010

Zul'Gurub

I've done the Zul'Gurub quests, and I want my raid back.

First of all, the quests that involve Zul'Gurub would have worked just as well in an instance as they did on the world map. You never walk in through the front door, you get teleported in and do strange little tasks.

Second, they took maybe 10 minutes in total, all of them put together.

I can't entirely rule out the possibility that we will be sent back there at higher level, but if you are so far Wowhead knows nothing about it.

I realize that no one even set foot in Zul'Gurub aside from a few dedicated mount collectors, but what they put in to justify removing it doesn't have a whole lot of value either. My position is clear skewed by the fact that I was one of those people farming for a mount, but comparing what was given up to what was put in its place - and the development lost plus the development that was put into the new stuff - it seems like a bad trade.

Wednesday, November 3, 2010

Power Word: Barrier

We were promised Power Word: Barrier some time ago1 but it ended up being cut. I believe this was because they just weren't getting it to work the way they wanted to. At the time I remember thinking it was a very difficult spell to implement. Obviously one way to implement an AoE shield is just to dump an individual shield on each person in an area, but that doesn't really have the right feel to it.

The implementation they came up with fits the idea of standing under a big shield that you share with your friends. The shield has a certain amount of damage it can absorb in total, but also a limit per hit so that if one person takes a massive hit they don't hog the whole shield.

The problem with this implementation is what happens when you cast it just one person. I'll use level 80 examples because they are more in our familiar range of understanding at this point. If you have around 4000 spell power then the shield can take about 51.6k, with 10.3k being the maximum per hit. If you cast that in front of the boss where the tank is standing then the tank gets 10.3k off every hit for the next five hits before the shield collapses. If a boss is swinging for 25k damage, this is basically Pain Suppression. If a boss is swinging for 35k then it's only 28% damage reduction, but that's an awful lot. What's important, though, is that it is a 52k instant cast heal on a single target in 10.3k installments. Think of it as a stupidly overpowered Renew.

Compare this to its AoE use. Suppose you are fighting the 10 player Sindragosa encounter. Her frost aura does 3750 damage every three seconds - and will be reduced by almost exactly 20% by resists. If non-tanks have an average of three stacks of mystic buffet, and they are gathered up under a shield, that means the shield will be block two ticks of the aura. This is not really that impressive. In fact, considering the positional requirements, it is arguable that Prayer of Mending is equally powerful or more powerful for this application, and that has a 10 second cooldown instead of a 2 minute cooldown.

For single massive AoE blasts there is a good chance that Power Word: Barrier will be inordinately effective. This is because, most likely, each person under the barrier will benefit from the full reduction of the barrier from a single hit even if that total overwhelms the total absorb of the barrier. That is, if your entire 25-player raid is standing under the barrier when the Lich King casts infest, it probably blocks 10.3k from each person, despite the fact that this means it absorbed over four times its maximum amount. This would be consistent with the behaviour of Anti-Magic Field, the spell that Power Word: Barrier was clearly based on. If the code does not have this mistake then it would basically be a 2-minute cooldown double strength Prayer of Healing.

Power Word: Barrier is good for two things: 1) For use as an external damage reduction cooldown on an individual who is standing in an isolated location or who is not standing near anyone else who will be taking damage; and 2) To take the edge off a powerful AoE attack that hits the entire raid when the raid can afford to stand together in preparation for the attack assuming that the way the coding works allows it to absorb far more than is intended.

When they announced Power Word: Barrier I really wasn't sure what kind of mechanics they could use to make it work. Clearly, they want it to have the thematic idea of sharing the shield between the people under it rather than giving each person their own shield. That requires a very large shield to be useful, but they certainly don't want it to be a super single-target shield.

These are some very significant problems to overcome. Unfortunately the design they settled on does not overcome them. The most likely outcome of Power Word: Barrier is that discipline priests will be seen as the external tanking cooldown healer - and will quite possibly be overpowered for this reason.


1. I believe they first announced it for patch 3.1, but it might have been 3.2

Tuesday, October 26, 2010

Shadow Word: Death

I should complain more about non-priest issues, but with all these changes it's hard to take my focus on things that affect Sthenno directly.

Shadow Word: Death was doing too much damage, and too much damage to the priests casting it, as I mentioned in a recent post. They decided to divide the damage it was doing by four and multiply the damage on low health targets by three to solve this problem.

I wonder if they considered amounts other than 75% to reduce the damage by. There are, after all, lots of numbers between 0 and 75%. They could have, for example, reduced the damage by 20%, or 25%, or even 40%, rather than reducing it so low that the damage per execute time is lower than Mind Flay.

If the damage of a spell, when cast on targets above 25% health, is so terribly low that it's always a dps loss to cast it, then why not only make it castable on targets below 25% health? There are lots of other spells that have that restriction, and it seems to work fine for them. Making it good sub 25% and castable but terrible at 25.01% might not be the best way to handle the spell.

But of course we may end up having to cast it above 25% anyway. Since a talent makes taking damage from it restore 10% of our total mana, it's kind of like Life Tap. It differs from Life Tap in a couple of key ways, of course. For example, has the upside that it does a little bit of damage but the downside that you can't use it between fights or during downtime when there is nothing to shoot. Another difference from Life Tap is that the damage you do to yourself can be prevented to cancel the effect, so if a Discipline priest gets so much as a critical Renew tick then our Life Tap fails. It also has a 12 second cooldown to make sure we can't spend too much of our time doing extremely low damage to the enemies. The cooldown goes away when the enemy is under 25% - that is, there is no cooldown when the spell actually does a ton of damage.

It seems like a number of different people all thought of changes to this spell and all implemented them without thinking about how they actually interacted with one another.

If they want it to be an Execute, they should make it an Execute. If they want it to restore mana, they should make it restore mana. If they want Shadow Priests to do several thousand dps to themselves once the boss gets under 25% health then they should probably just go ahead and rethink what they want. Right now this spell has too many conditions and add-ons, and it needs to be sorted out.

Friday, October 15, 2010

Those Who Did Not Learn From History

In Patch 3.2, Blizzard decided to remove Seal of Blood and Seal of the Martyr from the game. They decided that doing a lot of damage to yourself was not a good way to balance out doing a lot of damage to your opponent. In 3.1 they had already reduced the judgement damage and increased the seal damage to try to make the self-damage aspect of the seal less spiky. Paladins were knocking off a third of their life every eight seconds and it seemed pretty excessive and dangerous.

Strangely, though, the mechanic of damaging yourself to maximize your damage rotation has made a comeback in patch 4. By reintroducing Shadow Word: Death into the shadow priest rotation - that is, by making Shadow Word: Death hit like a truck - blizzard has put Shadow Priests in the position of giving themselves a good punch every 12 seconds. Given that Shadow Priest mana return is dependent on taking damage from Shadow Word: Death, there will be no escaping the self-damage.

Shadow Word: Death hits for somewhere in the mid- to high-six thousand range completely unbuffed. With raid buffs that could rise to somewhere in the neighborhood of 7500. A critical would be 15k. Shadow priests take 60% of this damage and immediate heal themselves for 25% of the damage dealt, so they effectively take 35% of this assuming they live to get the Vampiric Embrace tick. That comes out to around just over 15% of their health pool every 12 seconds. This is nowhere near former Retribution paladin self-damage levels, especially considering the constant, substantial self-healing that Shadow priests get.

The real problem is that when the enemy is below 25% health, the cooldown is removed from Shadow Word: Death and it does 30% more damage. Instead of 15% of their health pool every 12 seconds, it becomes 20% of their health pool every two or three seconds. That level of self-damage is completely astronomical, and not killing yourself becomes one of the major limiting factors for damage. If you get a big crit, you may have to worry about not getting that Vampiric Embrace tick because you are already dead.

Blizzard just nerfed Shadow Word: Death because Shadow priest damage was too high anyway, and Shadow priests were doing way too much damage to themselves on low health enemies. This change, however, reminds me a bit of the patch 3.1 paladin changes. After Wrath launched it took them quite a while to figure out that doing damage to yourself is not a good way to balance a dps class. Ultimately, I think they may have to learn this lesson again in Cataclysm.

Thursday, October 14, 2010

The Problem with Atonement

Recently I made a big post talking about how a Smite build compared to a Heal build for discipline priests. I tried it out last night and it turns out it doesn't work nearly as well as I'd hoped. This, of course, is mostly owing to the fact that on the live servers rather than healing a nearby friend for 100% of the damage that Smite deals, Atonement does nothing at all. I hope they figure out how to fix this one sooner than they fixed Surge of Light in Burning Crusade.

Tuesday, August 10, 2010

10-man Heroic

We've been at a 30% buff for a while now and still no guilds have killed heroic Lich King on 10-player without having 25-player gear. It's not time to throw in the towel yet, but at this point I feel like I can say that 10-player raids in Wrath were a great but failed attempt at providing an alternative for players who prefer the smaller raid size.

There is a good chance that Blizzard developers actually agree with a great deal of the criticisms I have to 10-player raiding in Wrath. They are, after all, significantly changing the paradigm for Cataclysm to eliminate the gear gap and prevent people from running raids of both sizes every week.

It has been fairly clear from the beginning that designers were designing 25-player bosses, and then just nerfing some numbers to get the 10-player version. Sartharion plus three drakes was our early proof of this. With the limited staff available to handle the multiple drakes at the same time, the 10-player version was widely recognized as being harder, person for person and gear for gear than the 25-player version. Were it not for the viability of rushes, that would still remain a fight that a relatively small number of players had beaten even with today's gear. In order to beat that fight we were forced to gear up in 25-player content. To my knowledge no one ever won in 10-player gear.

In Ulduar encounter design got better, but the 10-player version of encounters had several glaring problems. Often the solution to a 10-player predicament was to remove a troublesome mechanic altogether. Impacts of other mechanics on groups of different sizes, such as the mind control ability of Guardians of Yogg-Saron weren't even considered.

Ulduar was still a masterpiece, and it was great that they reduced the gap between 10-player and 25-player gear, but ToC brought that gap back. Moreover, the ToC trinkets were itemized so differently that the 25-player versions were great and the 10-player versions were universally terrible. While 25-player players were using on 245 and one 258 trinket, most 10-player players were using one 219 and one 200 trinket, because even the 245 10-player trinket wasn't worth equipping.

The trinket problems continued into ICC. With only one new trinket for each type, and those trinkets being unique between the heroic and non-heroic version, 10-player raiders got to upgrade only one trinket slot, while 25-player raiders got to upgrade both, often with very substantial upgrades. 25-player raiders also got Shadowmourne and are still benefiting from Val'anyr. 10-player raiders, on the other hand, can find noticeable holes in the gear offered to them, such as (at least at the time of release) there being no wand without hit in ICC. In ToC 10-player raiders could only upgrade their 219 cloaks (or 226 cloaks from 25-player Kel'Thuzad who we needed to kill to beat Sarth +3) completing a successful tribute run. No other cloaks were in the dungeon at all.

All the while 10-player guilds have to contend with a great deal of difficulty in recruiting because of the perception (and frankly, the reality) that they are second class raiding guilds. Attempts to recruit the best players were hamstrung from the beginning because most players would rather play at the difficulty level that gives the best loot. With 25-player normal giving the same loot at 10-player heroic, which is comparatively very hard, there is little incentive to join a guild dedicated to 10-player raiding.

25-player guilds got to trivialize 10-player content by overgearing it and having lots of extra practice at it. The limited attempts system ensured that they would take that time practicing as well. Probably more importantly, a 25-player guild attempting to get 10-player kills can bring in extreme raid compositions that are ideal for the encounter. 10-player guilds may only have one member of any given class, or none at all. 25-player guilds will almost always have two of each class and often three. If one class shines on a particular encounter, they will always be able to bring them. Imagine the poor 10-player guild who makes it all the way to heroic LK without a priest and then finds themselves at a desperate disadvantage due to having no shields for Infest.

All of this, however, brings me back to the Lich King. I don't know whether my guild will beat him or not. It may be we just need a hundred or two more attempts to get the fight down, but it may be that we are simply not up to the challenge. I don't doubt that this is our fault; there are probably many different groups of 10 people in the world who could beat the lich king on heroic with our characters. But none of them actually play 10-player exclusively. 10-player heroic Lich King has been, up to this point, nothing but a source of higher level weapons for guilds working on 25-player Lich King. The next few months will determine whether he ever becomes anything more than that.

Part of it is that I'm just disappointed that we haven't been able to win. Part of it is that I wish I was better at playing and I could stop making mistakes that are costing us attempts. But there is definitely a part of me that feels like being 14th in the world should mean we are good enough to take things down, and at the very least 1st in the world should.

Ultimately, for 10-player raiders, the final boss of the expansion was balanced to be out of reach. He is not out of reach for a theoretical raid, but he is out of reach for the people who are actually playing the game. I hope that someone can prove me wrong before 4.0 hits or he is nerfed (and I would love it if that someone is me) but at this point I would probably be willing to put even money against it.

Monday, July 12, 2010

Guild Perks

In an early preview of Cataclysm, one of the selling features was guild talents. The idea was that your guild would go up levels based on participation from the players, and then you'd get talent points to invest in a tree that would benefit your entire guild.

Since then the developers have decided that having an actual talent tree is probably a bad idea. Choices are fun, but in the case of guild talents they would be fun only for those who got to make the choice, and they would be a source of strife and drama for the multitudes who didn't get to be involved in that decision making process. For example, they said, suppose you are in a guild because you are friends with the other guild members. They all raid while you mostly PvP. They will choose raiding guild talents and you will be faced with a tough choice that doesn't add to anyone's fun: stick with your friends for the social aspect of the guild or leave for a guild that chose the PvP talents to support your playstyle. Instead, they have opted to get rid of the talent trees and give guilds "perks" as they level up. Basically it's all the same content, but with no choices involved and all guilds get all the perks.

A very good point, but it carried with it a strong implication that ran contrary to how I assumed guild talents would work. They were basically saying there would be guild talents that made you better at PvP and PvE. Talents that would have enough of an effect to leave you feeling handicapped by not having them. Is the problem really the choice and the guild drama, or is the problem that this sort of talent exists in the first place?

WoW.com had a view of the current state of guild perks a couple of weeks ago. If you haven't seen them yet then take a moment to look at them before you continue.

The talents that the developers would be concerned about here are the talents that increase heroism and honor point gains by 10%. While most of the talents favour PvE over PvP, those are the only talents that have to do with gearing up and beating your enemies that you might feel really let down if you didn't have. The ability to summon your guild helps raiding and doesn't really do anything for PvP, but it's a minor convenience issue, not one that affects your progression.

The real problem is that these perks that increase the rate at which you can acquire last-tier's gear aren't a good idea in either system. They will feel pretty exciting when you first unlock them and start getting extra points, but several months into cataclysm all of the big guilds will have those perks. That will mean that everyone will expect to have the perks and rather than seeming like a bonus, not having them is going to seem like a penalty. No one will feel like they are getting 10% more honor points, but there will be people out there who feel like they are getting 9% less honor points. There will be people who want to start new guilds and can't because no one wants to join a guild without the perks. They will be a source of aggravation without being a source of satisfaction or fun.

Those aren't the only talents that fall into this category either. Getting more reagents when you use gathering professions is the same. Everyone is going to feel like "15% more" is the standard, and someone who chooses to be guildless or who plays in a very small guild of very casual players will just get 13% less. In fact this may be even more true for gathering professions than for honor/heroism points. The value of gathered materials is set by the market, so other people getting more directly devalues what you get. What is the reasoning behind imposing this on casual players?

There are lots of great examples of perks on the list. Instant mail between guild members, summoning a remote guild bank and having 10% of cash gains added to the guild bank are all spectacular. Perks that give personal benefits to the members of the guild are not good ideas as guild benefits because they do not benefit the guild. They benefit the members of the guild, which is a very different thing. Perks that give individual benefits mean that there is a selfish incentive for people to attach themselves to large established guilds over working with their own guild. This is an incentive the game does not need.

This is something that is particularly risky because once these benefits have been handed out it will create a lot of backlash if they are taken back. I hope that individualized benefits as guild perks can be stamped out entirely during the testing phase, before they go live. I don't have a huge interest in perks vs. talents (I would be the one choosing the talents anyway) but I do have an interest in the benefits given by them being guild benefits rather than individual benefits.

Thursday, June 10, 2010

Too Soon?

We've got talent previews for four classes for cataclysm at this point. As a priest there is a lot to be excited about. As a resto shaman there is nothing to be excited about. In fact, the attitude of a resto shaman I know was closer to "pissed" than "excited." Not only are there virtually no changes to the tree, but some changes that we pretty much received specific promises about didn't happen. There is still a talent for 5 points that is worth 2% extra healing per point.

Discipline Priests have 5 new talents, 6 talents moved around between tiers and quite a few substantial changes to the way they work. I tried to make a discipline build and if their goal was to give me interesting choices and to create a "cookie cutter" talent build that left 10 to 15 points left over to spend how I want then they were successful. They were probably even more successful at this in holy where I can see many different ways to spend my last 10-or-so points. In the resto shaman tree there two new talents, one talent has been removed and everything else is exactly the same as it was. My attempt as a resto shaman build left me feeling like there were very few places to spend my points, and ended up looking almost exactly like a current resto shaman build.

From Purification and Nature's Blessing I hope I can assume this tree is far from finished. Seems like they should have previewed three classes instead of two; there might be a lot fewer worried resto shamans out there right now.

Friday, June 4, 2010

Near Misses: Bosses that could have been great

I was looking at a list of the best bosses in Wrath of the Lich King today. I expect that since we are in pre-expansion season people will be compiling lots of lists of their favourite and least favourite parts of this expansion. There were some very good bosses in the expansion as well as some pretty mediocre ones, but I don't want to dwell on the good or the bad. Instead, when I looked at the list, I found myself thinking about the bosses that could have, or should have, been great but that weren't. I don't want to force anything in this list that doesn't belong, so I've only got four of them, but that's not to say I necessarily got them all. There are plenty of fights that didn't work out, but these are the fights where them not working out is a significant let down.

Ignis the Furnace Master: It might be a bit of an exaggeration to suggest that this fight could have been great but it at least could have been pretty good. It turned out, though, that the easiest way to win was to completely ignore the fight mechanics, have your tank stand in the water and tank the boss and all the adds, and just kill him before you got enough adds to be a problem. When we were doing this fight the "right" way it seemed pretty interesting. When we decided not to bother with all the fancy stuff and just burn him out it became a simple tank and spank. To fix this they really needed to make shattering the golems a more important part of the fight. Rather than shattering golems purely for the sake of getting golems off your back, if golem shatters actually advanced your cause in terms of winning the fight (for example, shattered golems drop an item that can be used to do massive damage to Ignis) then people would do this fight by shattering golems and we'd get a fairly good fight.

Twin Val'kyr: Importing Ikaruga to an MMO was a great idea, but unfortunately I feel like it just didn't work. Ultimately our successful strategy was for most of the raid to spend most of the time standing in a pile right behind the boss. It was a tank and spank where every 90 seconds there was a 50% chance they had to do something other than keep attacking. For the healers playing goalie with the white orbs it was a little more interesting, but it was still mostly just spamming raid heals. I truly wish this fight would have been awesome, but the black and white switching mechanic was kind of clumsy and the clumsiness of it meant that they didn't make you switch very much. This fight would need quite a significant redesign to live up to its promise, but a starting point would be to find a good technical way to let us switch colours on the fly. That would have opened a world of possibilities of encounter design they had to ignore.

Sindragosa: This fight seems like a lot of fun and is in many ways well executed, but it has two rather awful problems. The first is Chilled to the Bone, the mechanic that punishes auto-attacking characters. She punishes casters as well with Unchained Magic, but no matter how many casters you bring, she only punishes one of them. Each caster past the first is a full time dpser. Each auto-attacker, no matter how many you bring, is affected by Chilled to the Bone. That means stacking melee is bad. But much worse than this is the way the debuff is applied. The faster you attack the faster you get stacks, so rogues barely get to play. If you look at the top dps on World of Logs, rogues are very visibly absent from Sindragosa's charts. There hasn't been a fight in recent memory that so badly punished a particular class.

The second reason this fight didn't work out is because the initial phase of the fight is long and relatively easy and then it becomes very hard. After a few tries to get the hang of it, you rapidly get into a mode where you spend the majority of your boss fighting time doing boring stuff you have proved you can do dozens of times and a small minority of your time actually practicing the part you need to beat.

Why do I say Sindragosa was close to being a great fight? They could have made this fight a lot more fun to learn by doing a few simple things. Rearrange the Chilled to the Bone mechanic to make it apply more evenly to all auto-attacking dps. Reduce her health, enrage timer, and the length of ground phases, but leave the transition point to the end phase at the same amount of health. Basically by tweaking just a few numbers this fight could have been great instead of boring and frustrating (especially for our rogue who we refused to bring while we were trying to get our first kill).

Anub'arak: This fight is the grandfather of disappointments. Basically I think this fight is brilliantly designed and really unique but that it is effectively spoiled by three things, and also harmed by a missed opportunity on the developers' part.

The first is the limited attempt mechanic and the fact that you basically only got one attempt per week. This is really the fault of limited attempts not of Anub, but Anub had the misfortune of being the final boss of the one attempt instance, and that will forever mar my memory of this fight.

The second is the fact that a 50% healing debuff was mandatory for this fight. There are three classes that can provide this debuff (and warriors can't do it while tanking, which they might need to do), so in 25-player this was presumably never a problem. In 10-player it could be a big problem. This wasn't a case where it was really hard to win or one class was over-emphasized. When we attempted this fight without a mortal strike debuff we simply weren't doing any damage to Anub once the swarm was out. We'd hurt him, but he'd heal back up while we were killing adds. You may be nuts if your raid without the 13% spell damage debuff, but it isn't literally mandatory for any fight. This requirement was way out of line.

The third fatal flaw with this encounter is the need for a shield tank. Since the damage multiplier applied by the adds applied *after* blocking effects, a well geared block tank could take no damage at all while tanking them, where a similarly geared bear or death knight would be taking nearly 14k dps. We had the good fortune to be using a paladin and a warrior for our main tanks though ToC, but if we had been using a DK and a druid as we were in Naxx we basically wouldn't have been able to win.

Finally, this fight was a missed opportunity. The developers decided in ToC to drop the concept of multi-step hardmodes. In the future we won't have a fight like Yogg, Sartharion or Flame Leviathan, where you get to choose how hard a hardmode you want to do. It will just be hard or easy. Anub was a great chance for a multi-step hardmode. His hardmode was harder in three very different ways that could have been separated out: 1) Frost Patches don't respawn, 2) Adds spawn during the swarm phase and get shadow strike and 3) Swarm deals 20% instead of 10% health per second. I love multi-step hardmodes and the opportunity to practice at one level before moving on to the next. I have to assume they were abandoned because it was felt they took too much developer time, but it's a real shame. Especially on a fight where it would have been so easy to implement one.

And what about Anub's problems? All are extremely simple to solve. Get rid of the concept of limited attempts, reduce the healing of his swarm by half and make him immune to healing reduction effects (at least on 10-player), and change the way the stacking debuff works from the adds so that there isn't a 14k dps difference in the damage taken by shield and non-shield tanks.

I can't really blame them for trying limited attempts once to see how it worked out1, but the other two are so glaring as to seem unforgivable. This fight should be something I remember with awe the same way I think of KT, Yogg and Lich King. Instead it just seems like a nuisance.



1. I can't forgive them for using limited attempts again in ICC. It was terrible, terrible, terrible.

Wednesday, June 2, 2010

DoT Leveling

Since my main is a priest I am clearly going to level by casting DoTs on things and then ignoring them until they die. I used to love smiting my enemies down, but those days are well and truly gone.

Of course the thing that matters when you are killing swaths of enemies with DoTs is how much damage you can do with one or two DoTs. This typically meant that for DoT classes the only thing that mattered was spell power when leveling (and at max level as well, I suppose). With hasted DoTs adding ticks to the end of DoT length, we now have the possibility of increasing our damage through haste rating as well.

If you are wearing two-piece tier 9 then your Vampiric Touch ticks seven times1. That means you would need in 14.29% haste or more to add an extra tick to the end of your Vampiric Touch. If you have less haste the ticks will come faster but you won't actually get any more damage out of them. At level 80, that would require 469 haste. Here's some assumptions we'll use to figure out how much haste increases our damage:
  1. We have about 3700 spell power
  2. Darkness will be going away to be replaced by our 8% passive talent tree bonus
  3. Shadow Orbs will have no effect on our damage if all we do is cast VT and SW:P
With 3700 spell power, Vampiric Touch will do nearly 15400 damage. That 469 haste would give us an 8th tick, increasing the damage to 17600. 469 spell power, on the other hand, would increase the damage by only 1794. Haste wins! Well, haste wins as long as you have exactly the right amount of it, more or less doesn't affect your damage at all until the next multiple of 469. If we are casting Shadow Word: Pain as well then spell power beats out haste at 469, but if we get 547 haste - the amount required to get a sixth tick of Shadow Word: Pain - then haste pulls ahead again, despite the extra 78 haste having no impact on our Vampiric Touch damage.

But we all know that the amount of rating required to get 1% haste is going to go up massively between now and level 85. Here is a list of how much rating it would take to add one tick to your Vampiric Touch as you are leveling.

LevelRating for Extra VT Tick
80469
81668
82951
831354
841928

While one extra Vampiric Touch tick might do more for you than 469 extra spell power, it certainly does not do more for you than 1928 extra spell power. In fact, at that rating conversion, haste is worth less than 30% of spell power, and it is only worth that much if you have the right amount. 1800 haste rating, of course, is completely wasted.

What's the lesson? While leveling, ignore everything but intellect on gear. A piece of gear with haste may be better at level 80, but it will become obsolete in no time. Unless something is done about the rating conversion, haste will stay obsolete the entire expansion, just like all ratings will for all classes.

Side Note: Will single- or double- dotting be sufficient to kill things?
According to modelling tools, level 80 characters in exclusively quest greens can do about 2400 dps without raid buffs. That means the typical level 80 monster is about 5 to 6 seconds worth of modelled dps. Assuming our dps doesn't drop between level 80 and level 85 - which isn't necessarily a safe assumption, but lets run with it - that should put us up against mobs with around 30k to 35k health. We would be able to two-DoT for that much if we can gain around 1900 spell power - the resemblance between this and the amount of haste we need to get one extra tick on Vampiric Touch is surely coincidental.



1. If you threw away your tier 9 gear, run some heroics and buy yourself some gloves and shoulders for leveling and farming. Even at level 85 I doubt there will be anything better for mowing down large numbers of mobs.

Monday, May 31, 2010

Power Word: Shield (Rank 12)

In Burning Crusade the developers did a lot of tinkering with downranking. When the expansion first came out, downranked spells were super fantastic. While spell power accounts for a lower percentage of healing than it does for damage, lowering the base effect to lower the mana cost was a trade people were all too happy to make. In fact, it hardly made any sense to cast your most powerful rank of a healing spell in any situation, since they generally cost quite a lot more and only healed for a comparatively small amount more. They put in some arcane calculations to make downranking worse by lowering the spell power coefficients of spells that were learned at levels lower than a character's current level. These occasionally even lowered the spell power of your highest rank of a spell, since sometimes the highest rank was learned more than 5 levels before you hit max level. In Wrath they decided to kill downranking once and for all by making lower ranks of spells cost the same amount as higher ranks.

Despite this, I've been casting a lot of Power Word: Shield (Rank 12) recently. With the ICC buff and a fully powered Demonic Pact I could be shielding around eleven thousand damage. Or I could cast a shield two ranks lower and shield around seven and a half thousand damage. Same cost, just a worse effect; that's what I'm doing.

Discipline priests get a lot of mana return from Rapture. Rapture gives back 2.5% of the caster's maximum mana every time one a shield breaks. It does not give back any mana if the shield expires without breaking, even if the shield only has 1 point of absorb left. This effect can only occur every 12 seconds, but if multiple shields break at precisely the same time, the 12 second cooldown is unable to trigger in time, allowing all of them to return mana. Normally you wouldn't even consider this, as 30 seconds is a long time for a shield to absorb all the damage its going to absorb. But there are a number of factors at play that make downranking the right move on Lich King.
  1. Infest does just a little less damage than is required to break a full powered shield
  2. Because of the mechanics of infest it is not acceptable to let one shield cover two consecutive casts; each infest must hit a fresh shield
  3. The lich king has no other splash or AoE damage during phase one
  4. The mana return from Rapture is necessary to keep up with the healing demands of the fight
Heroic 10-player Lich King does 11.7k to 13.2k damage with Infest. This is reduced by resistances, which average 20%, and reduced by Renewed Hope, making the average hit 9680. If I cast a fully powered Power Word: Shield then the shield would hold against this damage. The only way the infest breaks the shield is if it rolls near max damage (13,218) and the victim gets only a 10% resist (about a 25% chance). This will happen sometimes, but much less than most of the time.

Infest from heroic Lich King is a serious problem that the healers don't have a lot of leeway to deal with. Allowing the debuff to be applied to more than one or two non-tanks probably means it will be fatal, which means a wipe. If someone takes 9680 through a 7300 point shield then they end up taking 2380 damage. As this is less than 10% of their maximum health, they infest debuff will fall off immediately. If the same person gets an 11k shield then the first infest reduces that to a 1320 shield. That means the next infest will do over 8000 damage to them on average, and they will need heals to clear the debuff unless their total health is over 80k. Because your buffer to avoid the Infest debuff is your shield + 10% of your health, the two smaller shield approach generally allows the target to take more than 10.5k and still not get the debuff. The single large shield approach, however, doesn't get to use the 10% health buff from the first infest. In order to succeed at preventing the infest debuff from two consecutive infests it would need to be enormous, in excess of 16k shielded. This won't be reached even with a 30% ICC zone buff and level 277 gear.

Therefore a shield is needed for each non-tank for every infest. In addition to that, there is no real difference between someone coming out of an infest with 90% health and someone coming out with 100% health. Judgement of Light or other splashing heals will heal them to full before the next infest. Given that, the larger shield doesn't actually protect any better than the smaller one.

Finally, the mana cost of healing lich king is extreme. Infest happens every 23-25 seconds, usually closer to 23. With eight shields per infest, that means spending over 230 mana a second on shields alone. Since nearly every GCD is spent on one of Renew, Penance or Flash Heal, mana spent per second on this fight is probably around 500 for priests. Discounting Rapture, 2500 mp5 is not an attainable goal. If my shields never break to infest, that is what would be needed to keep up with the healing. With shields breaking on every infest, that's over 800 mana times 8 shields every 23 seconds. By downranking, Rapture is providing about 1400 mp5. It is also providing 2% mana every 23 seconds to other casters in the raid (about 40% of a replenish) and rage, runic power and energy to the non-mana users in non-trivial amounts.

Rapture has has this problem for a long time, but for a long time there was no circumstance where it could rightly be called a problem. The developers did this because they were solving another problem: they didn't want discipline priests to simply cast shields for mana regen when they were running around. Rapture is only supposed to give you mana back if you are actually using the shield to prevent damage, not if you are casting it just for fun. I can understand that goal. They didn't think much of the problem that having shields that were too large could prevent you from getting your mana back. After all, what were the odds that discipline priests were going to start complaining that their shields were too large?

It took a very strange confluence of events to make discipline priests worry about their shields being too large. But it just happened to happen on the encounter that is the culmination of the entire expansion. It also happened to happen on an encounter where discipline priests are favoured (some would say required) for healing. While resto druids are complaining that they don't have the tools to heal infest, discipline priests are busy intentionally reducing their best spell by a third of its power to properly deal with infest.

Is all of this a mere quibble? What difference does it really make if I downrank on one fight because of a bizarre mechanic?

The problem it causes is that it makes how powerful I am seem irrelevant. If I had more spell power I would just have to drop another rank of Power Word: Shield, and having the wrong amount of spell power might be a disaster. More crit wouldn't be benefiting that task at all. I spend nearly the entire fight under the effects of Borrowed Time so my haste hits a soft cap around 154 rating and does very little after that point. With the massive mana regen from Rapture and Infest I have no use for additional Int.

I've also considered redoing my spec to get rid of Improved Power Word: Shield. But what would I take in it's place? The lich king has no effects that are affected by Unbreakable Will. Reducing my threat with Silent Resolve would similarly have no effect. Should I put two points in absolution to save myself 250-300 mana over the course of the entire fight?

There may be a non-facetious argument in favour of switching my gems to stamina, a bizarre situation to say the least.

My gear doesn't feel like it's making me better, my talent points are wasted in talents that aren't helping just because the alternatives don't help either, and I am intentionally throwing away a third of the effect of my most powerful and often cast spell. Time to go take on the hardest boss in the world!

Wednesday, May 26, 2010

Spell Power Coefficients & The Real World

Disclaimer: I run strictly run 10-player raids. The point I am making here is a point about how spell power coefficients distort how the game is actually played and the decisions we make. I believe the particular example doesn't necessarily work in 25-player raids.

Recently I was reading a blog post at Penance Priest about how to heal as a discipline priest. The central theme of the post is very good advice, and advice that actually applies very well to most classes these days, not just discipline priests.

But I'm not really going to comment on that post, I'm only bringing it up because it reminded me of a recent change I've made in the way I play. The post casually mentions that Renew is terrible. And it's natural that it mentions this casually, as a sort of passing joke, because every discipline priest knows that Renew is a bad spell for discipline. We know this because we started this expansion with around 2k spell power. Renew heals for:

(1400 + (1.88 * spell power)) * 1.05 [Twin Disciplines] * 1.04 [Focused Power]

That's 5635 healing with 2000 spell power. You could get it to 6480 if you took Improved Renew, but Renew is bad, so you don't take Improved Renew.

At the same time, Flash Heal heals for for:

(2040 + (0.806 * spell power)) * 1.04 [Focused Power] * (1 + crit chance * .95)

Flash Heal healed (and shielded with Divine Aegis) for 5241. So if you are willing to wait 15 seconds for your healing you could get about 7.5% more. This is not much of a trade-off. Even if you ignore crits and spend the talent points on Improved Renew you would need three Renew ticks to equal a Flash Heal.

But we don't have 2000 spell power anymore. In fact, we can have more upwards of 4500 with a demonology warlock in the raid. With 4500 spell power Renew heals for 10800 while Flash Heal heals for 8130. Now if we ignore crits and spend the talent points on renew we need 2.4 ticks to equal a Flash Heal. Renew improved about 25% relative to Flash Heal over the course of the expansion.



Even compared to Power Word: Shield, Renew is still looking like something you might want to cast sometimes (given that Weakened Soul is a thing). I've mentioned before that I realized at some point that I didn't want to be using shields to raid heal on Blood Queen because I want to save them for pacts. What do I do with my GCDs when I am not shielding? I was casting Flash Heal at first, but now I cast Renew. What do I do when one healer is ice tombed and the other one has unstable magic on Sindragosa? I cast shield on anyone at low health and pre-emptively throw renews around. What do I do when it's almost Bonestorm time on Marrowgar? I put Renews on people and keep shields for when I see who actually needs them.

In other words, I behave the way that I think the developers imagined I would behave when they were designing things. Renew is a preemptive heal against damage I know is coming, Penance is to bring someone's health up, Shield is for emergencies and to deal with attacks that do enough damage to actually threaten to kill people in a couple of seconds. The nature of the spells, ignoring the particulars, suggests this is how you would want to play.

It is the particulars that made Renew useless. Power Word: Shield is still a better spell, and Flash Heal still has lots of use. But with sufficient spell power, Renew has lots of use as well. Discipline priests rarely use Renew because we all took it off our bars so long ago. But as spell power has over doubled in the expansion, the value of Renew has radically changed compared to the alternatives. As I've said before, the coefficients of spells should bear a resemblance to the power - or intended power - of the spells, not to the duration or cast time. The result of the current system was the extreme distortion of the power of Renew and a "generation" of discipline priests who don't look twice at a meaningful part of their toolbox.

Thursday, April 8, 2010

Levelling Up

If you've played WoW for five years you know that while the game has held onto a lot of very important thematic elements the difference in game play between now and the original release is staggering. Even just over the last year since the release of Wrath of the Lich King the game has undergone some really significant revisions. Of course revisions are always made with the endgame in mind, but Blizzard has not skimped on those revisions that are targeted towards the leveling and questing experience.

When I leveled my first character, a druid, the best way I could find to beat enemies was Moonfire and auto-attack with my staff. Cat form, all abilities included, seemed to do less damage than just swinging whatever stick you had. Attack spells were costly compared to my mana regen and didn't really hit that hard (it was almost impossible to get any spell power gear). Moonfire and swing beat an enemy in about 20-30 seconds, and that was the best I could do.

It's a real testament to how bad the leveling process was for druids that when I later switched to a warrior I leveled as protection and was impressed by how easy it was. And these were the days when Battle Shout cost 20 and parries and dodges generated no rage (*way* before devastate).

Blizzard at some point decided that you should be able to run around and beat monsters, complete quests and go up levels pretty much no matter what class you pick and no matter what talent tree you go up. There are still a few trees that are obviously sub-par, but not as sub-par as the leveling options that many classes used to have.

But despite the efforts that have been made, a lot of classes need a serious overhaul for leveling, and it has a lot to do with talented spells and new abilities. By "new" I don't necessarily mean all that new, I just mean abilities that have been introduced since Classic. Talented abilities and these new abilities are generally not available at low level, and that means that abilities that you are supposed to have to make your character do things are abilities you might not get until level 40, 50, 60, 70 or 75.

Go make a paladin. So you cast a spell that last for 30 minutes then you auto-attack. Okay, no big deal, its just level one. Go train your level one ability, it's an aura you put on when you auto-attack. Well, still level one. What does level four hold? Judgement, a spell you actually cast, and you can cast it once every 10 seconds! So generally you cast it when you engage and enemy then you auto-attack until the enemy is dead. You also get blessing of might which makes you do more damage when you auto-attack. Level ten? Put up your buffs and auto-attack, though you can stun someone every minute if you like, but it doesn't do any damage. All through to level 20 you get a better selection of auras and blessings to have on yourself when you auto-attack. At level 20 you finally get another spell you can actually cast to defeat your enemies. It has an 8 second cooldown. It also costs so much mana that given the fact you have no mana regen, you will have to drink every three monsters if you actually try to use it, and it probably doesn't do a lot more damage then you normally do anyway. Probably best to auto-attack. At level 40 you can finally put a point into a talent that gives you mana back when you judge, so you have mana to use a spell other than judgement, though it's really level 42 before you can max it out and use it effectively. At level 45 you've put two points into another talent that will let you use Exorcism to hit your enemies, although only on an on-crit proc with your bad crit chance, and only ever 15 seconds even if you are lucky. By this point you've got a +15% bonus and a +10% bonus to the damage of Crusader Strike, an ability you don't even have yet. At level 50 you finally get Crusader Strike, and you are finally actually playing a retribution paladin. You hit buttons when you fight your enemies instead of just auto-attacking.

Blizzard wasn't happy that all elemental shamans did was cast lightning bolt so they gave them another spell to mix things up a bit. It's called lava burst and you get it at level 75. What about shamans who want to level up as elemental? They can cast lightning bolt until they are 75. Arcane mages basically aren't even playing until they get Arcane Blast at level 64.

Strangely enough, for hunters they actually got it right. They give hunters their mana regen aspect at level 20, despite the fact that it was added to the game in the expansion. They also lowered the cost of shots so hunters can afford to do more than auto-attack until they get steady shot at level 50.

There are actually easy solutions to all of the problems I've given here. In the case of mages, shamans and various other classes that get now-pivotal abilities late in life, just make more ranks of the ability and give it out sooner. Sure, you introduced in it an expansion, but that doesn't mean it has to be forever above the pre-expansion max level. For paladins the fix I often talk about with a paladin wielding friend of mine is to give paladins crusader strike at level 20, and to make it cost nothing. Is that somehow going to cause problems? Are holy paladins going to be broken because they can swing their terrible damage to spell power trade-off fast one handers for 200 by wasting a GCD? Having the kay abilities of a tree embodied by it's talents is fine, but when you hit level 10 and get your first talent point, you shouldn't look at a tree and say, "Well, half of this does nothing until I put the 51st point in." And no one should be auto-attacking their way to level 40, even if they get nice buffs to do it with.

Monday, March 15, 2010

Glyphs

Glyphs are terrible.

First of all, just like in my gems post, I should point out that I am very aware of the fact that glyphs are fantastic, especially considering the alternative to glyphs is not having glyphs.

Glyphs were a cool idea that worked out pretty badly. I have at least four gripes about glyphs, which I may, of course, add to in the future as I think about more problems with glyphs. They are:
  1. The level of your inscription skill bares no relation to glyph power
  2. Glyphs are mostly uninteresting and trend towards being more uninteresting all the time
  3. Many glyphs seem to have been abandoned as useless
  4. There are *really* not enough minor glyphs
First of all, the inscription skill is completely bizarre. The reason you skill up leatherworking is to make better leather items. You skill up jewelcrafting to cut high grades of gems. You skill up inscription to make equally powerful glyphs. While a few glyphs apply to class skills that are only attained at high level, and as such can't be used until high level, a lot of the "high level" glyphs are just as useful at level 15 as they are at level 80. Glyph of Fireball, a spell that mages get a level 1, requires 385 skill to create. This is not because they didn't want you to have it at low level. The glyph's item level is 6 and it requires level 15 (the level you get your first glyph slot) to use. It's just that if you want to use it at level 15, you'll need to get it from someone who is at least level 65 who makes it out of herbs found in Northrend.

On the other hand, Glyph of Pestilence only requires 75 skill to make despite requiring level 55 to use (since there are no death knights below level 55). Glyph of Power Word: Shield, the most important glyph by far for discipline priests, required 80 skill to use, so there is no correlation between skill to make and usefulness either.

Basically glyphs are assorted randomly at different skill levels and herb requirements. They had to do this to make inscription fit their skilling up paradigm, but it makes no sense whatsoever. If I started playing this game today, made a mage, and decided that inscriptions sounded cool, I would hit level 15, get my skill to 75, and my profession would give me the incredible Glyphs of Fire Ward, Frost Ward and Arcane Blast. So two spells I never cast and one I won't learn for 49 levels. Inscription is designed entirely with the idea that you have max skill in it. Until then the profession doesn't make sense.

When glyphs first came out, the idea seemed to be that you could modify your spells to give yourself different options. A spell might be faster but cost more, or do less damage but more healing, or have some other kiss/curse type effect. There were also those glyphs aimed at changing the way you play. In practice, half of the glyphs just gave spells a percentage boost and had no trade-off. So, of course, people use the ones that make the things do they flat out better rather then using the ones that change things around. Also in practice these "interesting" glyphs often made the spells just plain bad. So many of the trade-off glyphs started to vanish to be replaced by simple percentage boost glyphs. Many glyphs could just ultimately be replaced by "+2% damage" and no one would notice. It's a lot of work and game mechanics to accomplish this.

But the fact that glyphs have that kind of effect makes many of the glyphs pretty close to useless. If there are glyphs that give you 2%+ damage then you aren't going to take glyphs that don't directly add to damage. If there are glyphs that give you 2% more healing, or 2% more damage mitigation, then you are going to skip utility glyphs in favour of these as well. As a result, many utility glyphs seem to have just been abandoned completely as useless. Glyph of Mass Dispel reduces the mana cost of Mass Dispel by 35%. According to Armory Data Mining no one uses this glyph at all. Even if they are just rounding down the very small number of people who use it, that would still mean that more discipline priests are using Glyph of Divine Spirit than Glyph of Mass Dispel.

And who can blame them. When I was running ToC and Ulduar my spreadsheet told me that Glyph of Mass Dispel would be worth about 4 Mp5. With my ICC logs it would be worth zero. I haven't cast Mass Dispel in a while. Even if they upped the 35% to 100% it would still see little use, though some people might swap to it for particular fights and it would probably see use in PvP. Glyph of Barbaric Insults is similar. So are Feint, Entangling Roots, Scorch, and several other glyphs from every class. These glyphs aren't good, it seems like they can't be good, so they've just been left to die. But some of these glyphs are really pretty easy to rehabilitate. Up the damage percentage on Glyph of Scorch so that a Scorch mage does almost as much damage as a Fireball mage and you'd see at least a few people using it. Up the effect of Glyph of Rapid Fire so that it's overall contribution to your damage is somewhat similar to other hunter glyphs and people would use that too. Others, like Mass Dispel, might be rehabilitated best by making them into minor glyphs.

Which would help a lot with the last problem I'll talk about today with glyphs. There aren't enough minor glyphs, and the homogenization in their use is rather incredible. About 95% of priests use Glyph of Levitate. A similar number of druids use Glyph of Unburdened Rebirth. For every class there are the minor glyphs people use and the minor glyphs people don't use. Some degree of homogenization is inevitable with only six glyphs to choose from and three slots to fill, but even in quality of life improvements there is room for balance. It if fairly obvious that people value getting rid of reagent costs far above duration increases for self-cast spells. Just like the unused major glyphs, I get the feeling that minor glyphs are just seen as unimportant, and that the ones people don't use have just been left to die. Minor glyphs aren't terribly important, but if there is anywhere in the game where it would be nice to see variability in behaviour, this would be it. They want to see options in talent builds, sure, but that is very hard to do when talents are tied to your performance in your raiding role. Variability in a part of the game that should be appealing to people's personal taste for quality of life improvements shouldn't be as hard as that.

So what to do about these problems? The first one seems absolutely impossible to solve without significant new tech that is unlikely to be implemented just for one profession. I assume that when Cataclysm comes out there will be a new Greater Heal glyph that you'll need to be level 80 to create while many glyphs that can be made at level 5 will continue to be useless to characters under level 60. The other option is to put in lots more glyphs and actually make the low level ones worse than the high level ones. I don't see this happening.

The solution to uninteresting glyphs is to just nix them all. If something simply says, "Increase the effect of something you'd cast anyway X by 5%" then replace it with something better. Things that increase the effect of spells by 20% are meaningful as they probably rearrange the priority of your casts, but small percentage to commonly used spells really take away the meaning and intent of glyphs. Of course this would be a ridiculous amount of design work, and they would probably rather introduce new glyphs than rework old ones, but if people are using "X does 5% more" type glyphs now than unless the new glyphs are "X does 6% more" I don't see that people will use them.

I already said that a big part of the solution to glyphs no one uses might be to make some of them minor glyphs. I don't think this is appropriate for all of them, but it would sure work for Mass Dispel and Barbaric Insults. But another part of that solution is rebalancing the minor glyphs that no one takes, reducing the attractiveness of reagent-replacement glyphs by selling Light Feathers and Fish Oil at reagent vendors, and making at least six more minor glyphs for each class. If you only get a quarter rather than a half of the glyphs then which ones you take will inevitably be less of a foregone conclusion.

Of these solutions I think that the last one, including more minor glyphs, will probably come with Cataclysm. I have little hope that any of the others would ever be done. Two years from now we will still most likely be able to look upon Glyph of Feint and weep.

Thursday, March 11, 2010

Gems

Gems are terrible.

We all know that gems are great. Not only should you socket up all the gear that has sockets, but you should normally choose gear with sockets over gear without sockets because it ends up being substantially more powerful. That's not what I'm talking about. I mean that the concept of gems, while it sounds cool, just isn't working, and I think this is just going to get worse in Cataclysm.

A recent blue post confirmed that the "cost" of sockets in an item's budget is taken out of the most attractive stat on that item. Thus, tanking gear with sockets should have less stamina than tanking gear without, plate damage gear with sockets less strength, leather with sockets less agility and so on. But of course they really have more of these things. They have more because that's what you socket them for. This is why we prefer gear with sockets to gear without, because we can maximize the one stat we want.

And so the problem is really that there is one stat we want. Almost every class and spec has a stat that is better than the other stats by a fairly significant margin. Even if they have two stats that are about equally good there is always the plateau of high stats followed by the drop off to stats that are worth two-thirds, half or even less than half as much towards their main function.

Suppose you have one stat that is good and every other stat is worth at most two-thirds of that stat1, and that you can get a stat that is two-thirds as good in both of the colours that don't have your main stat.

Aside from heads that have metas, the typical pattern for socket bonuses is that matching a single socket gives a +4 bonus, matching two gives a +6 and matching three gives a +8. Epic gems are worth 20 stat points. How extreme do circumstances have to be for you to gem outside your best stat?

A single socket item is only worth matching the socket if you get your best stat out of it. So if your best stat is strength, match a non-red socket only if the socket bonus is strength.

A two socket item you should match only if one of the sockets is the same colour of your main stat. So if your best stat is strength and the item has a yellow and blue socket, you should just gem strength even if the socket bonus is strength. If one socket is red to begin with then matching the other is good as long as the socket bonus is one of those two-thirds stats.

A three socket item should be matched only if either one of the sockets is the same colour of your main stat and the socket bonus is your main stat or two of the sockets are the same colour of your main stat. So match gems if two of the sockets are red and the socket bonus stat is useful or if one of the sockets is red and the socket bonus stat is strength.

In any other case just gem strength.

And this example is designed to be very favourable to socket bonuses and to variety. In reality most dps wouldn't value any blue stat at even close to half of their main stat and most tanks wouldn't value any stat at half of stamina2 let alone two-thirds. This means people gem all stamina, they gem all strength, they gem all armor penetration. They use other colours of gems to match sockets only to turn on their meta-gem.

Sockets on dps plate might as well just be replaced with twenty strength and we'll be done with it. Sockets are little more than a very complicated system to let people trade in small amounts of a stat they really want for small amounts of hit to get as close as possible to the hit cap without going under.

With a number of the changes in cataclysm - such as clearly defining and accepting the idea that each class/spec has a best stat and the coming rating changes - I think we have every reason to believe that the difference between your best and second best stat are going to get even more extreme (with the possible exception of tanks). This will mean more gemming for your best stat no matter what type behaviour.

In order to redeem gems stats need to have a relatively equal value. One stat will always be better, but it should not be half again as good as other stats. Without that, gems will slip more and more into just being passive stat bonuses by a different name. Gear with gems lets people trade gold for item points.



1. On an item point basis. For example, this would mean that if your best stat was Strength then either haste or crit would be two-thirds as good and a blue stat would be two-thirds as good. If your best stat was stamina then a red and a yellow stat would be as good as stamina point for point, since stamina only costs two-thirds of other stats in terms of item budget. Similarly, if your best stat is spell power than a yellow or blue stat would be more than two-thirds as good as spell power. You can see from these examples that this is an idealized situation that is making stats seem more balanced than they are. The reality of stat imbalance is much more extreme.

2. Valuing a stat at half a stamina item point wise would mean valuing it at three quarters of a stamina point for point wise.